现代英语中be going to 和 will 有区别吗?我给学生讲的是可以通用。不知道错没有

比如说。He will be there tomorrow.可以说成He is going to be there tomorrow.吗?我总觉得第二句读着不怎么通
好像没这么复杂吧。我们用的是仁爱版英语。在语法部分,讲将来时,就用了这两种。这两种是将来是的两种不同形式。

will 表自然发生的事情
但是be going to 是表有计划将要发生的事情

例如:
tomorrow the weather will be rainy
而不能说是tomorrow the wearther is going to be rainy

i am going to arrive in australia next year
用will就不准确

因此
he is going to be there tomorrow 更加准确
温馨提示:答案为网友推荐,仅供参考
第1个回答  2009-10-02
Lesson Topic: Future Tense Using "Will" And "Be Going To"

Question: You are going out for lunch. You hear your boss saying that his shirt is ready at the dry cleaner's. You are a really faithful, helpful, and loyal employee. What do you say?

1. I'm going to pick it up for you.
2. I'll pick it up for you.
3. Pick it up yourself! You, lazy bum!

C is a great answer if you want to get fired. If you don't want to get fired, we strongly recommend one of the others.

If you chose not to get fired, you are considering A and B. Which one is possible? Which one is best? Which one is usually said by a native speaker?

Both A and B are possible, but one is more common for a native speaker. Though will and be going to mean almost the same thing and are interchangeable sometimes, there are some situations when one is used more than the other.

Will

Promises
Johnny Mom, if I get 100 on my math test, will you take me out for ice cream?
Mom Yes, I'll take you out for ice cream. I promise.

Offers to help
Patricia I lost my ring
Brian No problem. I'll help you find it.

Request for help
Peter I need to change the oil in my car. Will you help me?
William Of course, I'll help you.
Would is even more polite in requests for help.

I need to change the oil in my car. Are you going to help me? is considered impolite.

Predictions about the future
Heather Some statisticians predict that there will be10 billion people in the world by 2050.
Melinda I think they are right. I heard there won't be enough food in the world for everyone.
Will is often used in predictions, but be going to is also used and acceptable.

Refusal of things
Walter I can't open this bottle of wine.
Sally Yeah. The cork won't come out.

Be Going To

State a plan or intention
Holly What are you going to do this summer?
Mandy I am going to travel across Europe. I am going to see everything from the Eiffel Tower to the Coliseum in Rome.

Back To The Quiz At The Top

Using the information we just learned about will and be going to, what is the answer to the quiz at the top of this lesson? The situation is an offer to help. Offers to help usually use will. Therefore, the answer is B. A is not wrong, but B is a little more common.

Quiz

Directions: Look at the following sentences. Rewrite the sentences in blue using will or the correct form of be going to.

1. My radio is broken. You (fix) it for me?

2. I have a two-week vacation in August. I (fly) to Vietnam.

3. My car ran out of* gas. It (not go).

*ran out of=used up all of (so there is no more)

4. My supervisor is a really nice guy. He promised me a big bonus this year. He promised me that he (give) me $2500 if we increase sales by 10%.

5. You spilled the milk. I (clean) it up.

1. My radio is broken. You (fix) it for me?

Answer: My radio is broken. Will you fix it for me?

Reason: Request for help

2. I have a two-week vacation in August. I (fly) to Vietnam.

Answer: I have a two-week vacation in August. I am going to fly to Vietnam.

Reason: Statement of plan or intention

3. My car ran out of gas. It (not go).

Answer: My car ran out of gas. It won't go.

Reason: Refusal of things

4. My supervisor is a really nice guy. He promised me a big bonus this year. He promised me that he (give) me $2500 if we increase sales by 10%.

Answer: My supervisor is a really nice guy. He promised me a big bonus this year. He promised me that he'll give me $2500 if we increase sales by 10%.

Reason: Promise

5. You spilled the milk. I (clean) it up.

Answer: You spilled the milk. I'll clean it up.

Reason: Offer to help
第2个回答  2009-09-28
will是计划做某事,多用于书面语。be going to 是已经计划好了,将要做某事,多用于口语;另外描述天气也多用于be going to 。
第3个回答  2009-09-28
楼上的说的不错!
相似回答